Sacri sacerdotii defensio contra Lutherum.

Cologne, [Hero Fuchs for] Peter Quentel, 1525.

8vo, ff. [68] (last leaf blank), gothic letter except for title and index, large woodcut on title of the royal arms of England supported by two putti, large and small woodcut initials; contemporary annotations, markings and underlinings throughout in red ink, the date ‘1526’ added in the same hand at the end of the text; small worm-track in first three leaves, just entering edge of woodcut arms on title. [bound after:]


US $3520€3083

Make an enquiry

RUPERT, of Deutz. De divinis officiis libri XII. [Cologne, Frans Birckmann,] 1526.

8vo, pp. [xlii], [iv, blank], 590, [2, blank], gothic letter, several large woodcut initials; a few annotations in the same hand as those in the Fisher; small worm-track in upper outer corner of first two leaves, just touching a few letters on verso of title.

Together two works in one volume; contemporary pigskin, covers blindstamped to a diaper design, two functioning clasps; soiled and slightly rubbed, later paper labels at head and foot of spine. £2750

I. John Fisher’s defence of the priesthood against the attacks of Luther. This is one of three editions to appear in 1525; of the three, that dated June 1525 (VD 16 F1240) is probably the first – its errata have here been corrected. The present edition contains a dedicatory epistle from the Dominican Johannes Host von Romberch to Arnold von Tongern not found in the earlier edition.

‘Fisher, who devotes the first section of his Defensio to the patristic sources, then turns to the Greek tradition in support of the mystical power of the priesthood. His use of Damascene, Gennadius, Cyril, Chrysostom, Gregory Nazianzen, Basil, Eusebius, Origen, Ignatius, Polycarp, ps.-Dionysius, Philo, and [ps.-]Clement, while obviously a product of almost uniquely deep learning, complements the Latin tradition . . . . Fisher is able to present an historical argument, for example by weaving a catena of patristic interpretations of the figure of Melchizedek, which defends the order of priesthood in a way that presents the reformers’ objections to ordination as anachronistic for locating the origins of the sacrament in comparatively recent history’ (Ralph Keen, ‘The Fathers in Counter-Reformation theology in the pre-Tridentine period’, in I. Backus, ed., The reception of the Church Fathers in the West from the Carolingians to the Maurists, 1997, vol. 2, pp. 701–44, pp. 731–2).

II. First published in folio earlier the same year by the same publisher. Rupert’s exegesis and theology, deeply concerned with such crucial questions as the nature of the Eucharist, the problem of evil, freedom and divine will, permeated medieval Western thought; his discussion on the mystery of the altar became central in Luther’s and Zwingli’s critique of the doctrine of the Sacraments.

Provenance: Ritter von Waldauf’schen library in Hall (Tyrol), with stamp on title of first work in volume and large engraved bookplate.

I. Adams F547; VD 16 F1238. OCLC records five locations in the US (Pierpont Morgan, Pontifical College Josephinum, Princeton Theological Seminary, Saint Bonaventure University, and United Library).
II. VD 16 R3783.

You may also be interested in...


Prince Arthur. An Heroick Poem. In Ten Books … London: Printed for Awnsham and John Churchil … 1695. [With:]
BLACKMORE, Richard. King Arthur. An Heroick Poem. In twelve Books … to which is annexed an Index, explaining the Names of Countrys, Citys, and Rivers, &c. London: Printed for Awnsham and John Churchil … and Jacob Tonson … 1697.

First edition of Blackmore’s first epic poem, with the first edition of its sequel – John Evelyn’s copies, with shelfmarks ‘E5:1’ and ‘E5:2’ in his hand, Prince Arthur additionally inscribed ‘Catalogo Evelini Inscriptus / Meliora Retinete’ (Evelyn’s motto: ‘Keep the best’).

Read more


Poetical Works.

Undated variant (presumably a later reissue) of Daly’s collected edition of 1839, read to pieces by the young Dante Gabriel Rossetti.

This volume has a well-documented history. Dante Gabriel consciously ‘adopted a nonchalantly bohemian lifestyle, rejecting his mother’s evangelical Anglican traditions’ (Oxford DNB). ‘Doughty records her alarm on hearing that he (aet. 16) “was reading indecent books”. Gabriel strenuously denied the accusation, which was due, he discovered, to his having expressed the intention to purchase a copy of Shelley’s poems. In spite of his mother’s suspicions, however, he bought the Shelley, and, as William Michael writes elsewhere, “surged through his pages like a flame”’ (Fredeman). William Michael and Christina, Dante Gabriel's close juniors, would perforce have been party to his enthusiasm.

Read more