REBUTTAL OF SAVONAROLA BY A FORMER ACOLYTE

Discorso … contra la dottrina, et le profetie di Fra Girolamo Savonarola.

Venice, Giolito, 1548.

8vo, ff. [viii], 100; printed in Roman and italic types; with woodcut printer’s device and numerous initials throughout; one or two instances of faint marginal dampstaining, but a very good copy in contemporary limp vellum.

£1500

Approximately:
US $2074€1738

Make an enquiry

Added to your basket:
Discorso … contra la dottrina, et le profetie di Fra Girolamo Savonarola.

Checkout now

First edition, very rare (‘raro e ricercato’, Bongi), of a condemnation of Savonarola’s theology, doctrine and prophecies by a former Savonarola acolyte, ‘one of the most fiery Catholic polemicists of his times’ (ibid., our translation), who four years earlier had published a confutation of Luther’s theology. The first part examines the attractiveness, plausibility and success of Savonarola’s preaching. Bishop Polito, a member of the same order as the Ferrarese friar, relives the times of his own past sympathies for Savonarola, and offers, with all the benefits of an insider’s outlook, an analysis of the reasons for Savonarola’s rise and popularity. Yet he finds Savonarola’s depiction of a corrupt Church (‘almost embodying the Antichrist, as the Lutherans say’, p. 8v.) grossly misrepresentative, and feels that heresy infiltrates Savonarola’s doctrines much as leprosy affects without remedy a body which might yet appear to have intact parts.

The second, more ponderous part is an examination of the hidden heretical qualities of Savonarola’s preaching. Bongi says that Polito’s refutation displeased many members of his order who cherished Savonarola’s memory and example, and that it in turn provoked refutations, such as Tommaso Neri’s Apologia of 1564.

Throughout the book, the author’s arguments and narrative are printed in italic types, in contrast with the roman type used to reproduce ample excerpts from Savonarola’s own works, systematically referenced in the shoulder notes.

Bongi I, p. 209-210; COPAC finds 3 copies in the UK (BL, Manchester, Oxford).

You may also be interested in...

ROME’S WATER SUPPLY AND FLOODING OF THE TIBER MODIO, Giovanni Battista.

Il Tevere ... doue si raggiona in generale della natura di tutte le acque, et in particolare di quella del fiume di Roma. Rome, Vincenzo Luchini, 1556.

[bound with:]
CASTIGLIONE, Giacomo. Trattato dell’inondatione del Tevere ... dove si discorre delle caggioni, e rimedij suoi, e si dichiarano alcune antichità, e luoghi di autori vecchi. Con una relatione del diluuio di Roma del 1598 ... E con un modo stupendo col quale si saluarono molte famiglie in Castel Sa[n]t’Angelo. Novamente posto in luce.

Rare first editions of two works on the river Tiber and the health implications of the quality of its water and of its regular flooding. A physician and follower of Filippo Neri, Modio (d. 1560) was moved to write Il Tevere by the regular flooding of the Tiber and subsequent sanitary crises in Rome (during which he fell gravely ill and was lucky to survive). Arguing against the findings of Alessandro Petronio in his De aqua Tiberina (1552), Modio demonstrates that the water of the Tiber was far from healthy and should not be drunk. Hippocrates had early established the importance of water-supply to health, and one of the chief glories of ancient Rome had been its water, and Modio here appeals to cardinal Ranuccio Farnese to push for the restoration of the city’s ancient aqueducts.

Read more

[FRANCE and ITALY.]

A collection of manuscript and printed material pertaining to French territorial ambitions in Italy.

A collection of memoranda concerning French ambitions in the Italian peninsula during the sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries.

Read more